Skip to content

Posts tagged ‘money’

What to do with Too Much of a Good Thing: How to Best Manage Large RRSPs and RRIFs During Retirement

Don’t get me wrong. I am a big fan of RRSPs when managed intelligently and have the backlog of past articles to prove it. On the other hand, contributing too much or vastly underestimating your investment prowess (or luck) can ultimately leave you with a potential tax problem during retirement and / or a draconian tax bill at death that can cause, depending where you live, over 50% or more of your RRSP or RRIF to vanish in the blink of an eye  and undermine a lot of the benefits of decades of financial discipline and sacrifice.  Accordingly, I often advise my clients with significant retirement assets to take a proactive approach to redeeming their RRSPs and RRIFs, as sometimes a little pain now is better than a lot of pain later, even if they are not around to feel it.  As everyone’s financial circumstances are different, please read the following suggestions with that in mind and use common sense to determine whether any of the suggestions I mention throughout this massive missive might make sense for you.

Basic Principles

As most of us know, the main benefits of contributing to RRSPs are the tax deduction you claim for contributing, plus the ability for your contributions to compound for perhaps decades without having to share any of the income or growth with the taxman. It’s even better if you ultimately withdraw the funds during your golden years when at a lower marginal rate on the deductions you earned when you made your RRSP contributions.  In fact, numerous calculations suggest that the benefits of contributing to a TFSA are often the same as contributing to a RRSP if the RRSP loot is taxed at the same rate on withdrawal as the tax rate applied when contributing in the first place.  Withdraw RRSP money at a lower tax rate than when contributing (provided it doesn’t interfere with income-related benefits like OAS and GIS) may even produce better results than investing the same funds in a TFSA. On the other hand, if withdrawing from a RRSP or RRIF  when in a higher tax bracket, including the quasi-tax that is the OAS clawback, and some or all of the benefits of RRSPs are lost.

Flexibility is a Wonderful Thing

As  a corollary of the truism that “cash is king,” one of my favourite retirement beliefs is that “non-registered money trumps all.”  Retirement is a long road inevitably full of surprises. Unless taking matters into their own hands, no one knows how long or short they will live, nor their spouse and other family members. As well, will there be emergency cash needs or ongoing increases in cash draws, such as when going into assisted living? Will the children or grandchildren need or benefit from a financial helping hand from time to time along the way? Or will you realize that you ultimately have more money than you’ll ever need and decide that you’d rather be around to reap the gratitude and see the results from providing family with an early inheritance or contributing to your favourite cause?

In all of those situations, it’s a lot easier and far less taxing (pun intended) to give non-registered cash than withdrawing large sums from RRSPs or RRIFs. In fact, if donating, gifting appreciated non-registered securities in kind provides tax credits for the value of the shares at donation, but the government also generally forgives any capital gains otherwise owing on the donated shares. Although TFSA withdrawals can also allow you to access cash without a tax hit, the opportunity cost of using cash that could continue to grow tax-free is a steep one. Accordingly, I generally recommend most retirees to accumulate a significant non-registered war chest for emergencies or to access when they’re feeling generous.

Being Suddenly Single Sucks

A lot of my clients can easily escape the higher tax brackets and OAS clawback when part of a marriage or common law relationship but end up paying through the nose when widowed and forced to declare the income and gains from both spouses’ assets on a single tax return. Accordingly, I often urge couples with appreciable RRSPs or RRIFs to take enough income each year to just avoid the OAS clawback when two spouses can share the tax burden in order to hopefully ease the tax pain (and increase the financial flexibility) if one of them is later left to fend for themself.

The Pros and Cons of Compounding

Although tax-deferred compounding can ultimately increase the size of RRSPs and RRIFs to truly impressive amounts, never ignore the tax consequences of having to pull out large amounts at high rates later, or the potentially ruinous rates at death.  Once it is time to start withdrawing from RRSP, you must convert them to RRIFs before the end of the year you turn 71 and must start pulling money out the following year. The minimum withdrawal is based on the balance at the beginning of each year multiplied by a percentage determined by the age of the accountholder or their spouse if that is selected at the time the account is created. The percentage increases yearly and, although the initial withdrawals may be manageable, they may ultimately require you to withdraw amounts that force  you to say goodbye to your OAS pension and put you in tax brackets you don’t enjoy in order to withdraw money that you don’t actually need that year.

Instead, making RRSP or RRIF withdrawals well before that age if at reasonable rates can keep your registered savings to a manageable size so that you have a better chance of avoiding high rates later.

Although you are paying tax albeit at lower rates earlier than necessary, there can be some benefits.  If it creates the necessary cash to fill up your TFSA or your spouse’s, then you can take comfort in knowing that you’ll never have to pay tax on those early withdrawals again. If financially secure, you might even use the money to fund your children or grandchildren’s TFSAs or First Home Savings Accounts. You might put the money into a grandchild’s RESP directly or by giving the money to their parents to do so, either a little each year or even by putting in the maximum amount of $50,000 all at once to take advantage of compounding in a different way. You could use the money for family vacations or to help children buy homes by way of an early inheritance.

Other options can include purchasing life insurance, which grows and is paid out tax free as another way of exchanging one type of compounding for another. As suggested earlier, you can invest the money into public securities and later donate them to charity, avoiding paying tax on their future growth but getting full tax credit for their value at the time of donation.  Finally, a buy and hold dividend hound investor not in the highest tax brackets can recoup some of the lost compounding from an early RRSP withdrawal since they will only pay tax on 50% of the subsequent growth vs 100% of any future growth inside the RRSP. On a similar note, dividends earned in a non-registered account can be extremely tax efficient for investors not dealing with OAS clawback. 

On the other hand, if using early RRSP withdrawals to invest in primarily interest paying investments, the benefits of accessing your cash early may be far less significant or even counter-productive, since their tax inefficiency and yearly taxation means that the money would compound far more rapidly if kept inside an RRSP until needed.

Moreover, always weigh the benefits of accessing money at lower rates now against losing future compounding on the portion of the withdrawal that goes to the taxman.  If already somewhat long in the tooth or sadly expect that you’re not long for this world, this future lost compounding is far less valuable than if you hopefully still have many decades left to celebrate life. And, if you really aren’t saving that much in taxes per dollar withdrawn now than what you’d pay later, then perhaps you’re better leaving well enough alone.  As in many areas of life, the right choice really does depend on the circumstances.

Know the Impact of the OAS Clawback

I view the OAS clawback as a tax and am not alone in doing so. Every dollar over the threshold is reduces your OAS pension by $.15 if income or interest.  If that dollar was capital gains, then only $.075 is lost since only 50% of gains are included for clawback calculation purposes. If that dollar was from investment dividends, that dollar will reduce your pension by $.207 due to the 138% gross up, while if that dividend was an ineligible dividend, such as paid from your holding company, that dividend dollar costs you $.1725 in OAS pension. On the somewhat bright side, the actual impact on your finances isn’t quite that bad, since you would have paid tax on the OAS pension you have now lost anyway, but the impact of the clawback can be like jumping up several tax brackets. For example, a Vancouverite forced to take too much RRSP or RRIF this year, resulting in a taxable income of $100,000,  would effectively be paying 41.35% tax on their last dollar of income:  a 31% marginal tax rate for income tax purposes plus an extra 10.35% in OAS clawback net of tax, which is actually a higher marginal rate than  someone earning $180,000 would pay on their last dollar. Enduring a little pain now to minimize the clawback later can really pay dividends (once more, pun intended.)

Strategies to Consider

Although one size does not fit all, here are some of the steps and strategies to consider if hoping to get the most out of your RRSP and RRIFs in your golden years:

  • If married, use the younger spouse’s age when setting up a RRIF. This reduces the minimum required yearly withdrawals and provides more flexibility in deciding how much to take out each year. You can always take out more than the minimum but this extra flexibility better allows you to manage your taxes.
  • As withdrawals from RRIFs if the accountholder is over 65 allow up to 50% to be taxed on your spouse’s tax return, which isn’t possible for RRSPs, be sure to convert to RRIFs before accessing your funds if of this age and your spouse is in a lower tax bracket.
  • If in good health, consider deferring OAS and also potentially CPP benefits to age 70. This can allow you to withdraw more RRSP or RRIF funds until then without worrying about OAS clawback so that you can keep more of your OAS in later years. Moreover, OAS and CPP are both indexed to inflation and pay you to defer starting these pensions by offering up to 42% more CPP and 36% more OAS monthly payments when you do start collecting.  The higher OAS payments also means that your total income before your OAS pension is completely wiped out each year is that much higher as well, which means that there is a greater chance that you’ll at least get to keep some of your OAS down the road.
  • Focus on investing tax efficiently in your non-registered accounts so that the tax hit from RRSP / RRIF withdrawals is better managed.  Although investment dividends can be a great choice for the right retiree, they are grossed up by 38% for tax purposes, which means that 138% of the actual dividend shows up as income on your tax return, which pushes investors into the clawback zone and higher rates that much sooner. As only 50% of capital gains are taxed, holding investments that focus on capital gains or offer tax-deferred  return of capital distributions are the most tax efficient for higher income retirees and can keep moderate income retirees out of the clawback zone completely or at least minimize the damage. Of course, tax considerations should not be the only factor in your mind when making investment decisions, although they should never be completely forgotten.
  • Use early RRSP / RRIF withdrawals to help future generations or your favourite causes, either immediately or by using the funds to pay  life insurance premiums for a policy you can leave to family or donate at death, or to invest the funds in publicly traded securities with potential capital gains that you can donate at a later date as described earlier, with the gains forgiven by the government but the entire value at donation credited when calculating the size of your donation.
  • Manage tax rates as a couple. I’ve done some calculations where a couple is actually better off by one completely losing their OAS pension and getting into the higher tax brackets while keeping the other spouse just under the OAS clawback threshold.
  • Investigate flow through shares, including bought deal flow through share offerings. The tax deductions and credits can help retirees keep more of their OAS pensions and ease the tax hit of larger mandatory RRIF withdrawals. Typical flow through shares or funds carry a lot of risk and will not be appropriate for many retirees.  I do love bought deal flow through share offerings for the right retirees, as they eliminate investment risk and essentially allow purchases to buy a tax deduction and tax credits in exchange for selling the underlying shares immediately after purchase at a discount. 
  • Know your tax brackets so you can determine how much you can withdraw at reasonable rates. One option is to take an educated guess early in the year or take conservative monthly payments and take a top up towards year end when your yearly income is easier to determine. At least taking enough to use up the entire lowest tax bracket or two in your province of residence is usually worth doing unless claiming GIS.
  • Start planning early!  Many people wait until forced to take their RRSPs or in the years leading up to then to start asking the right questions. It’s far better to start planning years before retirement so you can hit the ground running (or at least at a brisk walk if your joints aren’t what they used to be) when you do retire. Making spousal RRSP contributions along the way rather than typical RRSP contributions and taking withdrawals in low-income years prior to retirement can make a big difference in your results later in life. If you are a younger reader, there can be huge advantages from also developing a contribution strategy, which is something that I have written about previously but may revisit in the future.

Conclusion

Just like in so many areas of life, too much of a good thing can be a bad thing.  RRSPs can be a wonderful retirement funding tool but if not properly managed, many of their benefits can dissolve in pecuniarily high tax rates upon withdrawal or at death. I am particularly saddened when retirees pay unnecessarily higher rates on their RRIF withdrawals, including the effects of the OAS clawback, than the tax rate on their deduction when putting money into the plan in the first place.  I hope that some of the thoughts and strategies I’ve outlined today can help you get the most out of all of the RRSP and RRIF dollars you’ve worked so hard to accumulate.