Skip to content

Savvy Charitable Giving: How to Lend A Helping Hand Without It Costing You An Arm and A Leg

Our tax system is designed to encourage us to be generous. If donating personally, we qualify for a tax credit that reduces what we owe the government. If donating corporately, donations create a tax deduction that flows cash back into the corporate coffers. However, all donations are not treated the same. Knowing the best time, entity and way to give can ultimately have a profound impact on either your cost of giving or the size of your donation. Today, I will spell out the rules of the game and provide some tips to make your charitable donation dollars go that much further.

Personal Gifting Rules

While amongst the land of the living, unless you live in Quebec where this limit does not apply, you can claim a donation credit up to 75% of that year’s net taxable income. The first $200 produces a federal tax credit of 14% and the rest generates as much as 33% back in your hands if in the top tax bracket. Each province provides additional credits on top of what the feds offer. In BC, for example, the first $200 generates a combined credit of approximately 19% and gifts above that amount can offer as much as 53.5% cash back if in the highest tax bracket. Albertans receive back 74% of the first $200 and as much as 54% on the rest. Ontario, in comparison, has a bad case of Scrooge, with approximately 19% in combined credits on the first $200, but only 44% in combined credits on the excess, and then only if the donor is in the top tax bracket.

If you generously contribute more than you can deduct in one year, you can carry forward the excess to claim over the ensuring 5 years. Moreover, in the year of death, the maximum donation increases to 100% of your income, with any extra eligible to be carried back a year. There are also extra rules for carrying forward donations after death that can be vital for larger gifts, but which merit a separate article and thus no extra words at this time.

Before moving on to more complex stuff, here are some basic tips to hopefully make the most of your personal giving:

  • Except if you live in Alberta, where each spouse can get back 75% of the first $200 donated, it often makes sense for one spouse to claim both spouses’ combined donations on a single tax return. Elsewhere, the typical tax credit on the first $200 donated is a mere pittance. By pooling contributions, a smart and generous couple starts getting a higher donation credit as soon as their combined credits top $200 rather than when they separately gift that amount. In BC, that might mean an extra $69 back at tax time.
  • For wealthier couples, it’s often better for the higher income spouse to claim both spouses’ donations. The feds and provinces like BC offer a higher donation credit to donors in the highest tax bracket. Federally, this can mean an extra 4% back per dollar over $200 donated. In my province of BC, this savings increases to extra 7.8% coming back if you’re in the highest tax bracket but your spouse is not.  In other words, a savvy couple from Saanich donating $100,000 could save as much $7,800 if the higher income spouse claims the credits. Moreover, since the maximum yearly donation is 75% of a donor’s income, couples making larger donations can ultimately claim more and carry forward less of larger donations if the higher earner is the one claims the credit.
  • As in most things, there are exceptions to the rules:
    • If both spouses are in the highest bracket, they might want to keep their donations separate since the extra tax credit for givers in the top tax bracket only matches how much of their total income is taxed at that rate. In other words, if both spouses have $50,000 of their total income taxed at the highest rate and they each donated $50,000, only $50,000 of their combined giving would qualify for the maximum donation rate if one spouse claimed both donations.
    • In Alberta, it usually makes sense for one spouse to donate $1,000 and the other spouse to donate and claim the rest because of the supercharged donation credit offered in Wild Rose Country on the first $1,000 contributed.
    • For larger gifts where some of the donations will be carried forward, couples should consider whose incomes will be higher in the future years to maximize their tax savings when using up the unused credits and minimize how long they need to wait to do so. Ultimately, this could mean each spouse gifting and claiming separately, particularly when both are in the highest tax bracket.
  • As you get more bang for the buck when donating in the highest tax bracket, consider planning ahead to make larger donations when in the highest tax bracket, taking advantage of high tax years, such as when selling real estate, to make larger donations or even deliberately increasing your taxable income when planning to give big, such as if desiring to melt down your RRSPs or RRIFs. Along these same lines, those potential donors with bloated RRIFs will be in the highest tax bracket in the year of death. Accordingly, donating at death through Wills or beneficiary designations can be particularly rewarding, even if you aren’t around to reap the accolades.
  • If planning to move provinces, know the gifting rules and rates before you pull up stakes. If moving to a more generous province, consider curtailing your gifting until after the move. If the reverse is true, it might make sense to give a little more before changing your province of residence.
  • If in a hurry to claim carried forward credits or running up against the 5-year carryforward deadline, consider triggering capital gains or drawing down your RRSP / RRIF.
  • Always keep in mind the difference between tax deductions and tax credits. Since tax credits do not decrease your taxable income, donating will not help you protect your OAS pension or other income-related government benefits. On the other hand, for some givers who aren’t in the higher tax brackets, having their donations treated as a credit rather than as a deduction can ultimately mean getting back a tax refund higher than the tax paid on their last dollar.

Corporate Gifting Rules

Unlike personal gifting, which generates the tax credit that I just explained in excruciating detail, corporate gifting creates a tax deduction. It is, however, subject to the same cap of 75% of that year’s taxable income and 5-year carryforward on unused donations. For an active business that is only paying taxes at the discounted small business rate, this refund may be small potatoes, such as 11% in BC. For active businesses with income in excess of the small business limit, the benefits of the deduction can climb to 27% in my province of residence.

On the other hand, companies pay far more tax on investment income. Accordingly, claiming a tax deduction against what a company earns from its stocks and bonds can be a really big deal. In BC, that might mean 50.67% in corporate tax savings. The true benefits, however, can be a lot more complicated to calculate. If the money could instead be paid out to shareholders in not particularly scary tax brackets, the tax savings might still be higher if they donated personally, since the company’s tax bill on that investment income would be drastically reduced or eliminated through dividend or salary payments.

For a company that earns both active business income and investment profits, the deduction is applied first against business income, where the discount is far less meaningful. Accordingly, if you have a separate holding company exclusively for your investments, having the holdco do the gifting rather than your active business can be a huge tax saver.

Finally, as I’ll explain later in this article, when deciding whether to donate personally or corporately, it also depends in part on whether donating donates cash or in-kind, as well as the respective unrealized gains on the stocks that can be gifted. While both people or companies can and should consider donating stocks rather than dollars, there are some extra tax benefits when holding companies do the donating that can be a potential game changer. That will be covered in the next section.

In Kind Donation of Securities

For philanthropists that also enjoy investing, why not combine these two passions? Gifting publicly traded securities in kind rather than by writing a cheque can have a significant impact on your bottom line, as our government forgives the capital gains otherwise taxable while still crediting you or your donating corporation with the value of the donated security at the time of the gift. For example, if you own a stock worth $10,000 which you bought for $4,000, and you sold that investment, you’d be taxed on 50% of that $6,000 of growth. If in the highest tax rate and living in Langley, BC,  the tax bill would be $1,605. If donating those shares instead, you’d still get credit for a $10,000 donation but avoid the $1,605 tax bill. Put another way, instead of stroking a cheque for $10,000, donating this investment in kind generates an extra 16.05% in savings. Assuming you had already donated $200 to another cause, this $10,000 act of generosity has only really cost you $3,005.

If donating corporately, the results can be even better. Not only is taxable 50% of the gain ignored when calculating your tax bill and your holdco credited with a $10,000 tax deduction, but the entire $6,000 gain can be paid out to shareholders as a tax-free capital dividend. For shareholders trying to get more money out of their companies at lower rates, trying to avoid the OAS clawback while accessing corporate dollars or trying to minimize the tax bill on their company shares at death, creating and using tax-free capital dividends by donating shares rather than having to pay out taxable dividends can be a vital component of their financial planning toolbox.

Here are a couple quick points if looking to donate in kind:

  • Donate investments with the biggest unrealized gains or stocks that you were looking to sell anyway for portfolio management reasons.
  • If you love your stock with the biggest gain, donating it doesn’t mean you have to say goodbye. Unlike when you sell an investment with a capital loss, there is no rule that prohibits you from buying back the next day. If not liquidating your entire position and are planning on donating more of it in the future, consider one of the following: convince your spouse or kids to buy it back instead, buy it in a different type of account or buy something slightly different. That is because the cost of any repurchased shares in any of your non-registered accounts or in the same company’s name will be blended with the average purchase price of your remaining shares. This waters down your tax savings if you plan on donating more of the same investment in future years or if might want to do this later.
  • If planning on serial donations of the same stock over multiple years, consider making a bigger donation to a donor advised fund (“DAF”) now instead to get a bigger deduction up front, but spread your actual gifting to your charities out over time. The DAF will hold some of your donations on your behalf rather than gifting it all immediately to your charity of choice. Lump sum gifting also allows investors who love the stock they want to gift to repurchase their entire position in the same corporate or non-registered account the next day with a new ACB with no remaining unrealized gains, maximizing the future tax savings.

Whether you or your company is the one lending a helping hand, there can be logistical problems when donating in kind. Here are a few:

•           Many smaller charities are not set up to receive and sell stocks.

•           It may not be worth the hassle to donate in kind when making smaller gifts.

•           The best time to donate from a portfolio or tax management perspective may not always align with when you have the urge to give.

These are some of the reasons why you’ll want to read section on Donor Advised Funds and Community Foundations later in this article.

Where to Give – Personally or Corporately

Whether it is best to give personally or corporately can be a complex decision and really varies from situation to situation. With that substantial caveat in mind, some of the key factors to keep in mind are:

  • The respective unrealized gains on the different stocks that might be donated and where they are owned, as the higher the gain on the donated stock, the bigger the benefit.
    • The personal tax rate of the donor. Donors in lower tax brackets might get more bang for their buck when donating personally instead of corporately depending on their province of residence if the personal donation credit is higher than the donor’s marginal tax rate.
    • Are there any stocks you were planning on selling anyway for investment reasons and where are they located? Even if not the biggest gainers, donating one or more of these might make the most sense, as you can always donate some of your biggest winners in future tax years if you have no immediate plans to sell them.
    • Longer term planning. There are a bunch of other considerations that might lean you more to personal or corporate donations, such as estate planning and final tax bill considerations, estate freezes and whatever factors might apply in any individual situation.

Gifting Through a Middleman – Donor Advised Funds (“DAFs”) and Community Foundations

If it makes sense to make a large donation now but you want to spread the actual transfer to your charities out over time, hate the hassle of making separate in-kind donations to many charities per year or realize that the best time to donate from an investment or tax perspective isn’t always when you want to gift, a DAF or Community Foundation might be the answer. To keep things simple and to save on ink, I’ll refer to both as DAFs to save on ink going forward.

DAFs are entities that are already registered as charities or foundations. As a result, when you give them cash or securities, they provide an immediate charitable donation receipt. They then put the funds into a separate account within their structure. When you want your specific charities to actually get paid, you instruct the DAF accordingly and they can send along a cheque from your DAF account. Think of your DAF as your own charitable chequing or investment account. Fortunately, there are many different DAFs available in Canada and most big investment institutions have their own DAFs or connections to one. Moreover, most big cities also have their own Community Foundation, where contributions are earmarked for your choice of charities in that region. As well, different religious orders often have their own DAFs designed to support their causes.

Key benefits of your own DAF are as follows:

  • You can donate when it makes investment or tax sense and the funds stay in your DAF until you want to start disbursing funds, subject to any yearly minimum payout requirement (often 5%) of your account balance.
  • You don’t have the hassle of making separate in-kind donations every time you want to gift, as you can just stroke a cheque from your DAF account whenever the mood strikes.
  • You get the benefits of in-kind donations even if your ultimate charity of choice isn’t set up to receive in-kind donations.
  • You get the donation receipt and related tax savings up front rather than when the DAF pays the money out to your charities.
  • Subject to what charities the DAF includes, you have the flexibility to decide as you go where your money goes.

When deciding whether or not to use a DAF and which one to select, consider the following:

  • What fees do they charge?
  • How is your money managed inside the DAF and what is the DAF’s investment track record? Although you don’t get additional donation credits on growth once inside the DAF, future increases in value mean more to give and less need to refill the pot in the future.
  • Can your existing investment advisor continue to manage these funds or do you otherwise have a say in how they are invested.
  • Are your chosen charities included on their list?

Ultimately, these are only some of the considerations to contemplate when deciding whether or not to go the DAF route and picking the right DAF or Community Foundation. If making larger donations and want to save the considerable cost, administrative hassle and headache of creating your own private foundation, taking the time to investigate DAFs may be one of the best decisions you ever make.

Life Insurance Donations

Wishing to leave a large legacy at your death? Life insurance may be the answer. The most common way of donating is naming a charity as the beneficiary of a policy at your passing. When your time comes, the entire death benefit qualifies as a gift. As your biggest tax bill might be at that time and you reap the most tax-savings per dollar when you’re in the highest tax bracket, naming a charity to receive your insurance proceeds at death can help your charities while preserving more of your estate for your heirs. Moreover, during your lifetime, you’re free to change who gets the policy proceeds at your passing, such as if a more worthy charity arises or family member arises.  As the charity doesn’t get anything until your death, however, you don’t receive any tax relief during your lifetime.

Another option is to donate an existing policy to a charity while you’re still above ground. You’ll receive a tax credit equal to the value of the policy at that time, which is something an actuary would need to determine.  More specifically, the value is based on your age, health and ultimately how long you’ll likely live before the charity gets the insurance cheque. Think of it this way — if you likely only have a few years to live, even a policy with no cash value if you trade it in can be worth a considerable amount to a charity if they only have to wait a couple years before getting a very big cheque. Because you get a donation receipt at the time of gifting, there are no additional tax benefits at death or going forward, unless you continue to pay premiums on the policy. If so, you’ll get credit for these payments as well.

Unless you have a policy that you are thinking of cancelling anyway that you can donate, I prefer the donation at death alternative for flexibility purposes, although it’s always worth crunching the numbers, particularly if you want your tax relief now rather than having it benefit your heirs later.

Bought Deal Flow Through Shares

If your head isn’t already spinning, it’s time for a double shot of Advil and Red Bull. One of the most complex donation strategies involves buying and donating flow through shares in a single day to a DAF and then gifting to your charities of choice from there. There are at least 3 different companies in Canada that have been offering this alternative to Canadians for 15 plus years and have helped raise billions, even if you have likely never heard of them.

I don’t have the space and you likely don’t have the patience to hear the complete story, but I wanted to describe the basic premise as this can ultimately mean donating for pennies on the dollar – although I believe in the KISS technique, despite considerable evidence to the contrary, sometimes a little complexity is worth it.

In a nutshell, it works as follows. The company offering this strategy (“the offeror”) reaches out to a Canadian mining company, particularly those mining critical minerals, and institutional investors (“the liquidity provider”) who believe in that company. They all strike a deal whereby the mining company agrees to sell a special type of shares (“flow through shares”) that provide the buyer with an immediate tax deduction equal to the purchase price to the offer’s clients at a predetermined price. The liquidity provider agrees to purchase those same shares from the clients (or from the charity or DAF the clients choose) on the day of purchase at another predetermined discounted price. This prearranged sale to the liquidity provider removes any investment risk for the clients and is exception to the normal requirement that they wait four months to sell flow through shares on the open market. Despite losing money on the actual investment, clients in the top tax bracket ultimately come out ahead because of the tax savings.

Expanding on this, the clients get to deduct the entire purchase value and are ultimately taxed on only 50% of the discounted sales price, which is entirely a capital gain. The federal government and many provinces also offer significant tax credits to flow through investors in order to entice them to support this important industry. When the dust settles, investors can net an after-tax return of well over 20% in many cases with no investment risk.

If the clients instead donates some of the shares to a DAF, who then sells the shares to the liquidity provider at the preset price, the clients also gets credit for a charitable donation for the price paid by the liquidity provider, as well as the fee the clients pay to the offeror. Although donated flow through shares do not qualify for capital gains relief, the charitable donation credit, combined with the other tax savings already mentioned can ultimately mean that the clients can gift large sums with very little cost to themselves. And, if they have capital losses that can offset the capital gain on the ultimate sale price, the numbers get even better. As an alternative strategy, clients can do the flow through strategy for the tax savings without donating the flow through shares. If that same client wants to help charity, they can make in-kind donations of appreciated securities from their corporate or non-registered portfolios instead of donating the flow through shares.

There are many other pieces to this puzzle, and many other questions investors should ask before proceeding, but sophisticated investors backed by tax professionals might want to give this a look. For what it’s worth, I’ve done this personally, along with some of my clients, with success. On the other hand, if it looks too good to be true or has too many moving parts, there are certainly other many other avenues for giving that you should explore instead.

Conclusion

There are so many causes that deserve our support, even if we cannot all agree on which are most worthy. Our tax system encourages us to be generous, although not all gifts are treated equally. Although I don’t pretend that this article is all-inclusive, if you have successfully survived reading this article, I hope you have a better idea of the charitable donation rules and how to make your donation dollars go that much further.

In conclusion, a few warnings. First, only registered charities in good standing can provide charitable gifting receipts, not non-profit organizations. There are many organizations that do a lot of good, but which can’t provide you with tax receipts. If you are in doubt, visit the CRA website, which allows you confirm if your targeted recipient qualifies.

As a final warning, strongly consider professional advice when making larger gifting decisions, particularly if something looks too good to be true or has lots of moving parts. The CRA posts about charitable donation schemes it is investigating or disallowed and, although it can often take several years before the chickens come home to roost, the interest and penalty when that sad day finally arises can be devastating. A good accountant or financial planner can also help you navigate the complex tax rules so you can get the most out of giving, including potentially sharing a few ideas that I didn’t have the space to include today.

No comments yet

Leave a Reply