Skip to content

Posts tagged ‘finance’

Savvy Charitable Giving: How to Lend A Helping Hand Without It Costing You An Arm and A Leg

Our tax system is designed to encourage us to be generous. If donating personally, we qualify for a tax credit that reduces what we owe the government. If donating corporately, donations create a tax deduction that flows cash back into the corporate coffers. However, all donations are not treated the same. Knowing the best time, entity and way to give can ultimately have a profound impact on either your cost of giving or the size of your donation. Today, I will spell out the rules of the game and provide some tips to make your charitable donation dollars go that much further.

Personal Gifting Rules

While amongst the land of the living, unless you live in Quebec where this limit does not apply, you can claim a donation credit up to 75% of that year’s net taxable income. The first $200 produces a federal tax credit of 14% and the rest generates as much as 33% back in your hands if in the top tax bracket. Each province provides additional credits on top of what the feds offer. In BC, for example, the first $200 generates a combined credit of approximately 19% and gifts above that amount can offer as much as 53.5% cash back if in the highest tax bracket. Albertans receive back 74% of the first $200 and as much as 54% on the rest. Ontario, in comparison, has a bad case of Scrooge, with approximately 19% in combined credits on the first $200, but only 44% in combined credits on the excess, and then only if the donor is in the top tax bracket.

If you generously contribute more than you can deduct in one year, you can carry forward the excess to claim over the ensuring 5 years. Moreover, in the year of death, the maximum donation increases to 100% of your income, with any extra eligible to be carried back a year. There are also extra rules for carrying forward donations after death that can be vital for larger gifts, but which merit a separate article and thus no extra words at this time.

Before moving on to more complex stuff, here are some basic tips to hopefully make the most of your personal giving:

  • Except if you live in Alberta, where each spouse can get back 75% of the first $200 donated, it often makes sense for one spouse to claim both spouses’ combined donations on a single tax return. Elsewhere, the typical tax credit on the first $200 donated is a mere pittance. By pooling contributions, a smart and generous couple starts getting a higher donation credit as soon as their combined credits top $200 rather than when they separately gift that amount. In BC, that might mean an extra $69 back at tax time.
  • For wealthier couples, it’s often better for the higher income spouse to claim both spouses’ donations. The feds and provinces like BC offer a higher donation credit to donors in the highest tax bracket. Federally, this can mean an extra 4% back per dollar over $200 donated. In my province of BC, this savings increases to extra 7.8% coming back if you’re in the highest tax bracket but your spouse is not.  In other words, a savvy couple from Saanich donating $100,000 could save as much $7,800 if the higher income spouse claims the credits. Moreover, since the maximum yearly donation is 75% of a donor’s income, couples making larger donations can ultimately claim more and carry forward less of larger donations if the higher earner is the one claims the credit.
  • As in most things, there are exceptions to the rules:
    • If both spouses are in the highest bracket, they might want to keep their donations separate since the extra tax credit for givers in the top tax bracket only matches how much of their total income is taxed at that rate. In other words, if both spouses have $50,000 of their total income taxed at the highest rate and they each donated $50,000, only $50,000 of their combined giving would qualify for the maximum donation rate if one spouse claimed both donations.
    • In Alberta, it usually makes sense for one spouse to donate $1,000 and the other spouse to donate and claim the rest because of the supercharged donation credit offered in Wild Rose Country on the first $1,000 contributed.
    • For larger gifts where some of the donations will be carried forward, couples should consider whose incomes will be higher in the future years to maximize their tax savings when using up the unused credits and minimize how long they need to wait to do so. Ultimately, this could mean each spouse gifting and claiming separately, particularly when both are in the highest tax bracket.
  • As you get more bang for the buck when donating in the highest tax bracket, consider planning ahead to make larger donations when in the highest tax bracket, taking advantage of high tax years, such as when selling real estate, to make larger donations or even deliberately increasing your taxable income when planning to give big, such as if desiring to melt down your RRSPs or RRIFs. Along these same lines, those potential donors with bloated RRIFs will be in the highest tax bracket in the year of death. Accordingly, donating at death through Wills or beneficiary designations can be particularly rewarding, even if you aren’t around to reap the accolades.
  • If planning to move provinces, know the gifting rules and rates before you pull up stakes. If moving to a more generous province, consider curtailing your gifting until after the move. If the reverse is true, it might make sense to give a little more before changing your province of residence.
  • If in a hurry to claim carried forward credits or running up against the 5-year carryforward deadline, consider triggering capital gains or drawing down your RRSP / RRIF.
  • Always keep in mind the difference between tax deductions and tax credits. Since tax credits do not decrease your taxable income, donating will not help you protect your OAS pension or other income-related government benefits. On the other hand, for some givers who aren’t in the higher tax brackets, having their donations treated as a credit rather than as a deduction can ultimately mean getting back a tax refund higher than the tax paid on their last dollar.

Corporate Gifting Rules

Unlike personal gifting, which generates the tax credit that I just explained in excruciating detail, corporate gifting creates a tax deduction. It is, however, subject to the same cap of 75% of that year’s taxable income and 5-year carryforward on unused donations. For an active business that is only paying taxes at the discounted small business rate, this refund may be small potatoes, such as 11% in BC. For active businesses with income in excess of the small business limit, the benefits of the deduction can climb to 27% in my province of residence.

On the other hand, companies pay far more tax on investment income. Accordingly, claiming a tax deduction against what a company earns from its stocks and bonds can be a really big deal. In BC, that might mean 50.67% in corporate tax savings. The true benefits, however, can be a lot more complicated to calculate. If the money could instead be paid out to shareholders in not particularly scary tax brackets, the tax savings might still be higher if they donated personally, since the company’s tax bill on that investment income would be drastically reduced or eliminated through dividend or salary payments.

For a company that earns both active business income and investment profits, the deduction is applied first against business income, where the discount is far less meaningful. Accordingly, if you have a separate holding company exclusively for your investments, having the holdco do the gifting rather than your active business can be a huge tax saver.

Finally, as I’ll explain later in this article, when deciding whether to donate personally or corporately, it also depends in part on whether donating donates cash or in-kind, as well as the respective unrealized gains on the stocks that can be gifted. While both people or companies can and should consider donating stocks rather than dollars, there are some extra tax benefits when holding companies do the donating that can be a potential game changer. That will be covered in the next section.

In Kind Donation of Securities

For philanthropists that also enjoy investing, why not combine these two passions? Gifting publicly traded securities in kind rather than by writing a cheque can have a significant impact on your bottom line, as our government forgives the capital gains otherwise taxable while still crediting you or your donating corporation with the value of the donated security at the time of the gift. For example, if you own a stock worth $10,000 which you bought for $4,000, and you sold that investment, you’d be taxed on 50% of that $6,000 of growth. If in the highest tax rate and living in Langley, BC,  the tax bill would be $1,605. If donating those shares instead, you’d still get credit for a $10,000 donation but avoid the $1,605 tax bill. Put another way, instead of stroking a cheque for $10,000, donating this investment in kind generates an extra 16.05% in savings. Assuming you had already donated $200 to another cause, this $10,000 act of generosity has only really cost you $3,005.

If donating corporately, the results can be even better. Not only is taxable 50% of the gain ignored when calculating your tax bill and your holdco credited with a $10,000 tax deduction, but the entire $6,000 gain can be paid out to shareholders as a tax-free capital dividend. For shareholders trying to get more money out of their companies at lower rates, trying to avoid the OAS clawback while accessing corporate dollars or trying to minimize the tax bill on their company shares at death, creating and using tax-free capital dividends by donating shares rather than having to pay out taxable dividends can be a vital component of their financial planning toolbox.

Here are a couple quick points if looking to donate in kind:

  • Donate investments with the biggest unrealized gains or stocks that you were looking to sell anyway for portfolio management reasons.
  • If you love your stock with the biggest gain, donating it doesn’t mean you have to say goodbye. Unlike when you sell an investment with a capital loss, there is no rule that prohibits you from buying back the next day. If not liquidating your entire position and are planning on donating more of it in the future, consider one of the following: convince your spouse or kids to buy it back instead, buy it in a different type of account or buy something slightly different. That is because the cost of any repurchased shares in any of your non-registered accounts or in the same company’s name will be blended with the average purchase price of your remaining shares. This waters down your tax savings if you plan on donating more of the same investment in future years or if might want to do this later.
  • If planning on serial donations of the same stock over multiple years, consider making a bigger donation to a donor advised fund (“DAF”) now instead to get a bigger deduction up front, but spread your actual gifting to your charities out over time. The DAF will hold some of your donations on your behalf rather than gifting it all immediately to your charity of choice. Lump sum gifting also allows investors who love the stock they want to gift to repurchase their entire position in the same corporate or non-registered account the next day with a new ACB with no remaining unrealized gains, maximizing the future tax savings.

Whether you or your company is the one lending a helping hand, there can be logistical problems when donating in kind. Here are a few:

•           Many smaller charities are not set up to receive and sell stocks.

•           It may not be worth the hassle to donate in kind when making smaller gifts.

•           The best time to donate from a portfolio or tax management perspective may not always align with when you have the urge to give.

These are some of the reasons why you’ll want to read section on Donor Advised Funds and Community Foundations later in this article.

Where to Give – Personally or Corporately

Whether it is best to give personally or corporately can be a complex decision and really varies from situation to situation. With that substantial caveat in mind, some of the key factors to keep in mind are:

  • The respective unrealized gains on the different stocks that might be donated and where they are owned, as the higher the gain on the donated stock, the bigger the benefit.
    • The personal tax rate of the donor. Donors in lower tax brackets might get more bang for their buck when donating personally instead of corporately depending on their province of residence if the personal donation credit is higher than the donor’s marginal tax rate.
    • Are there any stocks you were planning on selling anyway for investment reasons and where are they located? Even if not the biggest gainers, donating one or more of these might make the most sense, as you can always donate some of your biggest winners in future tax years if you have no immediate plans to sell them.
    • Longer term planning. There are a bunch of other considerations that might lean you more to personal or corporate donations, such as estate planning and final tax bill considerations, estate freezes and whatever factors might apply in any individual situation.

Gifting Through a Middleman – Donor Advised Funds (“DAFs”) and Community Foundations

If it makes sense to make a large donation now but you want to spread the actual transfer to your charities out over time, hate the hassle of making separate in-kind donations to many charities per year or realize that the best time to donate from an investment or tax perspective isn’t always when you want to gift, a DAF or Community Foundation might be the answer. To keep things simple and to save on ink, I’ll refer to both as DAFs to save on ink going forward.

DAFs are entities that are already registered as charities or foundations. As a result, when you give them cash or securities, they provide an immediate charitable donation receipt. They then put the funds into a separate account within their structure. When you want your specific charities to actually get paid, you instruct the DAF accordingly and they can send along a cheque from your DAF account. Think of your DAF as your own charitable chequing or investment account. Fortunately, there are many different DAFs available in Canada and most big investment institutions have their own DAFs or connections to one. Moreover, most big cities also have their own Community Foundation, where contributions are earmarked for your choice of charities in that region. As well, different religious orders often have their own DAFs designed to support their causes.

Key benefits of your own DAF are as follows:

  • You can donate when it makes investment or tax sense and the funds stay in your DAF until you want to start disbursing funds, subject to any yearly minimum payout requirement (often 5%) of your account balance.
  • You don’t have the hassle of making separate in-kind donations every time you want to gift, as you can just stroke a cheque from your DAF account whenever the mood strikes.
  • You get the benefits of in-kind donations even if your ultimate charity of choice isn’t set up to receive in-kind donations.
  • You get the donation receipt and related tax savings up front rather than when the DAF pays the money out to your charities.
  • Subject to what charities the DAF includes, you have the flexibility to decide as you go where your money goes.

When deciding whether or not to use a DAF and which one to select, consider the following:

  • What fees do they charge?
  • How is your money managed inside the DAF and what is the DAF’s investment track record? Although you don’t get additional donation credits on growth once inside the DAF, future increases in value mean more to give and less need to refill the pot in the future.
  • Can your existing investment advisor continue to manage these funds or do you otherwise have a say in how they are invested.
  • Are your chosen charities included on their list?

Ultimately, these are only some of the considerations to contemplate when deciding whether or not to go the DAF route and picking the right DAF or Community Foundation. If making larger donations and want to save the considerable cost, administrative hassle and headache of creating your own private foundation, taking the time to investigate DAFs may be one of the best decisions you ever make.

Life Insurance Donations

Wishing to leave a large legacy at your death? Life insurance may be the answer. The most common way of donating is naming a charity as the beneficiary of a policy at your passing. When your time comes, the entire death benefit qualifies as a gift. As your biggest tax bill might be at that time and you reap the most tax-savings per dollar when you’re in the highest tax bracket, naming a charity to receive your insurance proceeds at death can help your charities while preserving more of your estate for your heirs. Moreover, during your lifetime, you’re free to change who gets the policy proceeds at your passing, such as if a more worthy charity arises or family member arises.  As the charity doesn’t get anything until your death, however, you don’t receive any tax relief during your lifetime.

Another option is to donate an existing policy to a charity while you’re still above ground. You’ll receive a tax credit equal to the value of the policy at that time, which is something an actuary would need to determine.  More specifically, the value is based on your age, health and ultimately how long you’ll likely live before the charity gets the insurance cheque. Think of it this way — if you likely only have a few years to live, even a policy with no cash value if you trade it in can be worth a considerable amount to a charity if they only have to wait a couple years before getting a very big cheque. Because you get a donation receipt at the time of gifting, there are no additional tax benefits at death or going forward, unless you continue to pay premiums on the policy. If so, you’ll get credit for these payments as well.

Unless you have a policy that you are thinking of cancelling anyway that you can donate, I prefer the donation at death alternative for flexibility purposes, although it’s always worth crunching the numbers, particularly if you want your tax relief now rather than having it benefit your heirs later.

Bought Deal Flow Through Shares

If your head isn’t already spinning, it’s time for a double shot of Advil and Red Bull. One of the most complex donation strategies involves buying and donating flow through shares in a single day to a DAF and then gifting to your charities of choice from there. There are at least 3 different companies in Canada that have been offering this alternative to Canadians for 15 plus years and have helped raise billions, even if you have likely never heard of them.

I don’t have the space and you likely don’t have the patience to hear the complete story, but I wanted to describe the basic premise as this can ultimately mean donating for pennies on the dollar – although I believe in the KISS technique, despite considerable evidence to the contrary, sometimes a little complexity is worth it.

In a nutshell, it works as follows. The company offering this strategy (“the offeror”) reaches out to a Canadian mining company, particularly those mining critical minerals, and institutional investors (“the liquidity provider”) who believe in that company. They all strike a deal whereby the mining company agrees to sell a special type of shares (“flow through shares”) that provide the buyer with an immediate tax deduction equal to the purchase price to the offer’s clients at a predetermined price. The liquidity provider agrees to purchase those same shares from the clients (or from the charity or DAF the clients choose) on the day of purchase at another predetermined discounted price. This prearranged sale to the liquidity provider removes any investment risk for the clients and is exception to the normal requirement that they wait four months to sell flow through shares on the open market. Despite losing money on the actual investment, clients in the top tax bracket ultimately come out ahead because of the tax savings.

Expanding on this, the clients get to deduct the entire purchase value and are ultimately taxed on only 50% of the discounted sales price, which is entirely a capital gain. The federal government and many provinces also offer significant tax credits to flow through investors in order to entice them to support this important industry. When the dust settles, investors can net an after-tax return of well over 20% in many cases with no investment risk.

If the clients instead donates some of the shares to a DAF, who then sells the shares to the liquidity provider at the preset price, the clients also gets credit for a charitable donation for the price paid by the liquidity provider, as well as the fee the clients pay to the offeror. Although donated flow through shares do not qualify for capital gains relief, the charitable donation credit, combined with the other tax savings already mentioned can ultimately mean that the clients can gift large sums with very little cost to themselves. And, if they have capital losses that can offset the capital gain on the ultimate sale price, the numbers get even better. As an alternative strategy, clients can do the flow through strategy for the tax savings without donating the flow through shares. If that same client wants to help charity, they can make in-kind donations of appreciated securities from their corporate or non-registered portfolios instead of donating the flow through shares.

There are many other pieces to this puzzle, and many other questions investors should ask before proceeding, but sophisticated investors backed by tax professionals might want to give this a look. For what it’s worth, I’ve done this personally, along with some of my clients, with success. On the other hand, if it looks too good to be true or has too many moving parts, there are certainly other many other avenues for giving that you should explore instead.

Conclusion

There are so many causes that deserve our support, even if we cannot all agree on which are most worthy. Our tax system encourages us to be generous, although not all gifts are treated equally. Although I don’t pretend that this article is all-inclusive, if you have successfully survived reading this article, I hope you have a better idea of the charitable donation rules and how to make your donation dollars go that much further.

In conclusion, a few warnings. First, only registered charities in good standing can provide charitable gifting receipts, not non-profit organizations. There are many organizations that do a lot of good, but which can’t provide you with tax receipts. If you are in doubt, visit the CRA website, which allows you confirm if your targeted recipient qualifies.

As a final warning, strongly consider professional advice when making larger gifting decisions, particularly if something looks too good to be true or has lots of moving parts. The CRA posts about charitable donation schemes it is investigating or disallowed and, although it can often take several years before the chickens come home to roost, the interest and penalty when that sad day finally arises can be devastating. A good accountant or financial planner can also help you navigate the complex tax rules so you can get the most out of giving, including potentially sharing a few ideas that I didn’t have the space to include today.

What to do with Too Much of a Good Thing: How to Best Manage Large RRSPs and RRIFs During Retirement

Don’t get me wrong. I am a big fan of RRSPs when managed intelligently and have the backlog of past articles to prove it. On the other hand, contributing too much or vastly underestimating your investment prowess (or luck) can ultimately leave you with a potential tax problem during retirement and / or a draconian tax bill at death that can cause, depending where you live, over 50% or more of your RRSP or RRIF to vanish in the blink of an eye  and undermine a lot of the benefits of decades of financial discipline and sacrifice.  Accordingly, I often advise my clients with significant retirement assets to take a proactive approach to redeeming their RRSPs and RRIFs, as sometimes a little pain now is better than a lot of pain later, even if they are not around to feel it.  As everyone’s financial circumstances are different, please read the following suggestions with that in mind and use common sense to determine whether any of the suggestions I mention throughout this massive missive might make sense for you.

Basic Principles

As most of us know, the main benefits of contributing to RRSPs are the tax deduction you claim for contributing, plus the ability for your contributions to compound for perhaps decades without having to share any of the income or growth with the taxman. It’s even better if you ultimately withdraw the funds during your golden years when at a lower marginal rate on the deductions you earned when you made your RRSP contributions.  In fact, numerous calculations suggest that the benefits of contributing to a TFSA are often the same as contributing to a RRSP if the RRSP loot is taxed at the same rate on withdrawal as the tax rate applied when contributing in the first place.  Withdraw RRSP money at a lower tax rate than when contributing (provided it doesn’t interfere with income-related benefits like OAS and GIS) may even produce better results than investing the same funds in a TFSA. On the other hand, if withdrawing from a RRSP or RRIF  when in a higher tax bracket, including the quasi-tax that is the OAS clawback, and some or all of the benefits of RRSPs are lost.

Flexibility is a Wonderful Thing

As  a corollary of the truism that “cash is king,” one of my favourite retirement beliefs is that “non-registered money trumps all.”  Retirement is a long road inevitably full of surprises. Unless taking matters into their own hands, no one knows how long or short they will live, nor their spouse and other family members. As well, will there be emergency cash needs or ongoing increases in cash draws, such as when going into assisted living? Will the children or grandchildren need or benefit from a financial helping hand from time to time along the way? Or will you realize that you ultimately have more money than you’ll ever need and decide that you’d rather be around to reap the gratitude and see the results from providing family with an early inheritance or contributing to your favourite cause?

In all of those situations, it’s a lot easier and far less taxing (pun intended) to give non-registered cash than withdrawing large sums from RRSPs or RRIFs. In fact, if donating, gifting appreciated non-registered securities in kind provides tax credits for the value of the shares at donation, but the government also generally forgives any capital gains otherwise owing on the donated shares. Although TFSA withdrawals can also allow you to access cash without a tax hit, the opportunity cost of using cash that could continue to grow tax-free is a steep one. Accordingly, I generally recommend most retirees to accumulate a significant non-registered war chest for emergencies or to access when they’re feeling generous.

Being Suddenly Single Sucks

A lot of my clients can easily escape the higher tax brackets and OAS clawback when part of a marriage or common law relationship but end up paying through the nose when widowed and forced to declare the income and gains from both spouses’ assets on a single tax return. Accordingly, I often urge couples with appreciable RRSPs or RRIFs to take enough income each year to just avoid the OAS clawback when two spouses can share the tax burden in order to hopefully ease the tax pain (and increase the financial flexibility) if one of them is later left to fend for themself.

The Pros and Cons of Compounding

Although tax-deferred compounding can ultimately increase the size of RRSPs and RRIFs to truly impressive amounts, never ignore the tax consequences of having to pull out large amounts at high rates later, or the potentially ruinous rates at death.  Once it is time to start withdrawing from RRSP, you must convert them to RRIFs before the end of the year you turn 71 and must start pulling money out the following year. The minimum withdrawal is based on the balance at the beginning of each year multiplied by a percentage determined by the age of the accountholder or their spouse if that is selected at the time the account is created. The percentage increases yearly and, although the initial withdrawals may be manageable, they may ultimately require you to withdraw amounts that force  you to say goodbye to your OAS pension and put you in tax brackets you don’t enjoy in order to withdraw money that you don’t actually need that year.

Instead, making RRSP or RRIF withdrawals well before that age if at reasonable rates can keep your registered savings to a manageable size so that you have a better chance of avoiding high rates later.

Although you are paying tax albeit at lower rates earlier than necessary, there can be some benefits.  If it creates the necessary cash to fill up your TFSA or your spouse’s, then you can take comfort in knowing that you’ll never have to pay tax on those early withdrawals again. If financially secure, you might even use the money to fund your children or grandchildren’s TFSAs or First Home Savings Accounts. You might put the money into a grandchild’s RESP directly or by giving the money to their parents to do so, either a little each year or even by putting in the maximum amount of $50,000 all at once to take advantage of compounding in a different way. You could use the money for family vacations or to help children buy homes by way of an early inheritance.

Other options can include purchasing life insurance, which grows and is paid out tax free as another way of exchanging one type of compounding for another. As suggested earlier, you can invest the money into public securities and later donate them to charity, avoiding paying tax on their future growth but getting full tax credit for their value at the time of donation.  Finally, a buy and hold dividend hound investor not in the highest tax brackets can recoup some of the lost compounding from an early RRSP withdrawal since they will only pay tax on 50% of the subsequent growth vs 100% of any future growth inside the RRSP. On a similar note, dividends earned in a non-registered account can be extremely tax efficient for investors not dealing with OAS clawback. 

On the other hand, if using early RRSP withdrawals to invest in primarily interest paying investments, the benefits of accessing your cash early may be far less significant or even counter-productive, since their tax inefficiency and yearly taxation means that the money would compound far more rapidly if kept inside an RRSP until needed.

Moreover, always weigh the benefits of accessing money at lower rates now against losing future compounding on the portion of the withdrawal that goes to the taxman.  If already somewhat long in the tooth or sadly expect that you’re not long for this world, this future lost compounding is far less valuable than if you hopefully still have many decades left to celebrate life. And, if you really aren’t saving that much in taxes per dollar withdrawn now than what you’d pay later, then perhaps you’re better leaving well enough alone.  As in many areas of life, the right choice really does depend on the circumstances.

Know the Impact of the OAS Clawback

I view the OAS clawback as a tax and am not alone in doing so. Every dollar over the threshold is reduces your OAS pension by $.15 if income or interest.  If that dollar was capital gains, then only $.075 is lost since only 50% of gains are included for clawback calculation purposes. If that dollar was from investment dividends, that dollar will reduce your pension by $.207 due to the 138% gross up, while if that dividend was an ineligible dividend, such as paid from your holding company, that dividend dollar costs you $.1725 in OAS pension. On the somewhat bright side, the actual impact on your finances isn’t quite that bad, since you would have paid tax on the OAS pension you have now lost anyway, but the impact of the clawback can be like jumping up several tax brackets. For example, a Vancouverite forced to take too much RRSP or RRIF this year, resulting in a taxable income of $100,000,  would effectively be paying 41.35% tax on their last dollar of income:  a 31% marginal tax rate for income tax purposes plus an extra 10.35% in OAS clawback net of tax, which is actually a higher marginal rate than  someone earning $180,000 would pay on their last dollar. Enduring a little pain now to minimize the clawback later can really pay dividends (once more, pun intended.)

Strategies to Consider

Although one size does not fit all, here are some of the steps and strategies to consider if hoping to get the most out of your RRSP and RRIFs in your golden years:

  • If married, use the younger spouse’s age when setting up a RRIF. This reduces the minimum required yearly withdrawals and provides more flexibility in deciding how much to take out each year. You can always take out more than the minimum but this extra flexibility better allows you to manage your taxes.
  • As withdrawals from RRIFs if the accountholder is over 65 allow up to 50% to be taxed on your spouse’s tax return, which isn’t possible for RRSPs, be sure to convert to RRIFs before accessing your funds if of this age and your spouse is in a lower tax bracket.
  • If in good health, consider deferring OAS and also potentially CPP benefits to age 70. This can allow you to withdraw more RRSP or RRIF funds until then without worrying about OAS clawback so that you can keep more of your OAS in later years. Moreover, OAS and CPP are both indexed to inflation and pay you to defer starting these pensions by offering up to 42% more CPP and 36% more OAS monthly payments when you do start collecting.  The higher OAS payments also means that your total income before your OAS pension is completely wiped out each year is that much higher as well, which means that there is a greater chance that you’ll at least get to keep some of your OAS down the road.
  • Focus on investing tax efficiently in your non-registered accounts so that the tax hit from RRSP / RRIF withdrawals is better managed.  Although investment dividends can be a great choice for the right retiree, they are grossed up by 38% for tax purposes, which means that 138% of the actual dividend shows up as income on your tax return, which pushes investors into the clawback zone and higher rates that much sooner. As only 50% of capital gains are taxed, holding investments that focus on capital gains or offer tax-deferred  return of capital distributions are the most tax efficient for higher income retirees and can keep moderate income retirees out of the clawback zone completely or at least minimize the damage. Of course, tax considerations should not be the only factor in your mind when making investment decisions, although they should never be completely forgotten.
  • Use early RRSP / RRIF withdrawals to help future generations or your favourite causes, either immediately or by using the funds to pay  life insurance premiums for a policy you can leave to family or donate at death, or to invest the funds in publicly traded securities with potential capital gains that you can donate at a later date as described earlier, with the gains forgiven by the government but the entire value at donation credited when calculating the size of your donation.
  • Manage tax rates as a couple. I’ve done some calculations where a couple is actually better off by one completely losing their OAS pension and getting into the higher tax brackets while keeping the other spouse just under the OAS clawback threshold.
  • Investigate flow through shares, including bought deal flow through share offerings. The tax deductions and credits can help retirees keep more of their OAS pensions and ease the tax hit of larger mandatory RRIF withdrawals. Typical flow through shares or funds carry a lot of risk and will not be appropriate for many retirees.  I do love bought deal flow through share offerings for the right retirees, as they eliminate investment risk and essentially allow purchases to buy a tax deduction and tax credits in exchange for selling the underlying shares immediately after purchase at a discount. 
  • Know your tax brackets so you can determine how much you can withdraw at reasonable rates. One option is to take an educated guess early in the year or take conservative monthly payments and take a top up towards year end when your yearly income is easier to determine. At least taking enough to use up the entire lowest tax bracket or two in your province of residence is usually worth doing unless claiming GIS.
  • Start planning early!  Many people wait until forced to take their RRSPs or in the years leading up to then to start asking the right questions. It’s far better to start planning years before retirement so you can hit the ground running (or at least at a brisk walk if your joints aren’t what they used to be) when you do retire. Making spousal RRSP contributions along the way rather than typical RRSP contributions and taking withdrawals in low-income years prior to retirement can make a big difference in your results later in life. If you are a younger reader, there can be huge advantages from also developing a contribution strategy, which is something that I have written about previously but may revisit in the future.

Conclusion

Just like in so many areas of life, too much of a good thing can be a bad thing.  RRSPs can be a wonderful retirement funding tool but if not properly managed, many of their benefits can dissolve in pecuniarily high tax rates upon withdrawal or at death. I am particularly saddened when retirees pay unnecessarily higher rates on their RRIF withdrawals, including the effects of the OAS clawback, than the tax rate on their deduction when putting money into the plan in the first place.  I hope that some of the thoughts and strategies I’ve outlined today can help you get the most out of all of the RRSP and RRIF dollars you’ve worked so hard to accumulate.

Advanced Mixology: The Strategic Use of Retirement Assets

(Or How to Thwart the Taxman, Maximize your Retirement Dollars and Sleep 18% Better)

When talking to with retirees, wanna be retirees or children helping their older parents manage their nickels, dimes and c-notes, it’s almost certain that the best way to deplete retirement assets will be part of the conversation. And, that’s exactly as it should be. A well-thought-out retirement strategy can lead to staggering tax savings, greater flexibility and, most importantly, the ability to sleep that much deeper at night knowing that you’ve done as much as reasonably possible to achieve your financial goals, which seldom means making unnecessarily large contributions to our friends in Ottawa.

I’ve written about many different aspects of retirement planning in previous articles, including a series on RRSP / RRIF withdrawals, but I wanted to pull a bunch of different ideas from my previous efforts together, along with some new points to help anyone faced with these conundrums.

What This Article Can’t Do

Despite my strong wishes to the contrary and no matter how pretty or detailed any cashflow projections may look, retirement planning remains a series of educated guesses, many of which will ultimately be off the mark, often within days. How many people predicted the huge spike in inflation following Covid? What about the changes to capital gains taxation in the last Federal Budget? Or the changes to small business taxation over the last 10 years? These examples do not even speak to the more obvious unknowns, like lifespan, income needs and investment returns. Moreover, on that last subject, those of you that have read my previous article on how the “sequences of returns” generated by your portfolio affects your long-term results, you’ll also know that all 7% average portfolio returns are not created equal – bad returns early in retirement can have a disastrous impact on later portfolio sizes, particularly if forced to liquidate capital during the downturns, regardless of later market corrections.

Accordingly, despite my wishes to the contrary, I cannot provide a one-size fits all roadmap, nor can I guarantee that any perfectly plausible plan I prepare today will still be the best way forward if one of life’s surprises strikes you squarely between the eyes. On the other hand, there are a lot of common-sense principles, mixed in with some basic math, that I think can help tilt the odds in your favour. Moreover, the larger your nest egg, the shorter your expected timespan wandering this wonderful world, and the more pessimistic your projections of things like investment returns or spending needs, the smaller the chance of things going drastically awry. Accordingly, despite my dire proclamations, I firmly believe that the benefits of proper planning can usually help you cope with future surprises, provide wiggle room if you need a little more or earn a little less,  and hopefully still save a lot of taxes along the way. Although we can’t predict the future, making reasonable assumptions, taking proactive steps and regularly reviewing your numbers are far better than merely shutting your eyes and hoping for the best.

Basic Philosophy

Noting all of these caveats and qualifiers, here are some of the things to consider when constructing your retirement funding plan.

Be Inflexible About Flexibility

As the future is impossible to predict, it’s vital to build flexibility into your plan. Flexibility can take many forms, such as:

  • Having enough liquid assets that can be accessed without triggering a huge tax bill in case of emergencies, or you don’t want to necessarily wait until you’re pushing up daisies before helping your kids and grandkids.  It’s even better if these are in addition to a max-funded TFSA, as using the TFSA to pay for emergencies can carry a huge opportunity cost, since this is the one retirement account that both grows and pays out completely tax-free. In some cases, as you’ll see when I throw some math in your general direction, it might even be better to bite the bullet and pull money from your RRIF instead or borrow.
  • A HELOC is a great insurance policy. Even if you have the money to pay for big expenses personally, it can sometimes make sense to borrow instead. For example, for a big expense coming due in December, borrowing to pay some of the cost so you can spread out and minimize the tax hit by triggering gains or withdrawing RRIF dollars over multiple years can save you far more in taxes than you pay in interest.  The HELOC also provides you with some breathing room while waiting for a market recovery before selling or waiting to sell real estate.
  • If a couple, plan for what finances will be like if one of you is on their own for many years. A lot of couples minimize their taxes and keep both their OAS pensions while both are above ground, but the survivor is often left dealing with a double whammy of less retirement income if all or most of the deceased’s pensions disappear, but a higher average tax rate on the reduced income since it is taxed on a single tax return. In many cases, it’s worth considering pulling out more RRIF money while you’re both hale and hearty so it can be split across two tax returns if concerned about the survivor being forced into higher tax brackets, or dealing with OAS clawback if you have accumulated significant RRSP/ RRIF savings.
  • Be willing to adjust your plans if a butterfly in Asia flaps its wings and throws off all of your previous plans off kilter. That means reviewing your situation from time to time and ensuring that you’re up to date with any external factors, like changes to tax rates or law that might mean that it’s now better to zig than to zag.
  • Be a pessimist. Run any projections on the basis that your investments just might not average 10% per year, you live to 100 and all of those dream vacations cost a little more than you expect. CFPs are required to run retirement projections using rates that might not top 5% and I suggest running one batch of retirement projections on this basis. At the very least, when making assumptions regarding investment returns, run projections using a range of assumptions and, if possible, use a Monte Carlo simulation rather than assuming your investments earn a constant yearly rate of return. A Monte Carlo simulation will randomize each year’s investment returns around your target return, with the maximum yearly high or low capped by how much you estimate returns might vary. The program might run 1,000 different projections, graph the results, and let you know what percentage of these projections didn’t result in you moving into your children’s basement and subsisting on cat food.

Income is Wonderful Thing, Particularly if Tax Efficient

I previously mentioned the impact of your sequence of returns on your retirement portfolio, particularly if you don’t own a yacht.  The more income your portfolio generates, the less capital you’ll need to liquidate to pay for golf and groceries. This goes hand in hand with a well-diversified portfolio that is designed to minimize volatility. That said, all types of income are not created equal. Interest income can be taxed at over 50% in some provinces in the hands of the well-to-do. Investing in interest-paying investments in a non-registered portfolio can accordingly come at a steep price, compared to other types of investments that can compound tax-free until needed. Instead, investments that pay eligible dividends are almost tax-free until your taxable income approaches the OAS clawback threshold in some provinces, which is around $93,000. In fact, if in the lowest tax bracket, eligible dividends can actually reduce your tax bill unless you’re receiving GIS, in which case, earning eligible dividends can be a financial disaster.

There are also investments that pay regular distributions through capital gains, such as covered call funds, and, even better, other investment that pay “return of capital,” which is treated as a return of your original investment dollars and is thus tax-free, although it will increase your eventual capital gains bill when selling down the road.  Private Real Estate Income Trusts (“REITs”) can provide return of capital distributions in the mid to high single digits and, since they are not initially taxed, they don’t need to generate as much income as less tax efficient investments to pay your hydro bills since, until you sell or are a long-time owner, what you receive is what you keep.  Moreover, their tax efficient nature also allows retirees wishing to draw down their RRIFs the opportunity to withdraw more than would otherwise be possible at lower rates or  without triggering OAS clawback.

Turning to Registered Plans, I suggest owning more of the interest payers, such as GICs, Mortgage Investment Corporations, bonds or bond funds, and Structured Notes, in those accounts. All types of income are treated the same in these accounts and these types of investments are generally very low volatility. Accordingly, since you’ll eventually be forced to make withdrawals from your RRIFs at one stage, regardless of your need or market conditions, owning these steady eddy investments in your RRIF also minimizes the impact of sequence of returns, particularly if you can increase withdrawals during bad times while you give your stock portfolio the time to recover.

And, if your investments don’t generate enough after-tax money to cover the life you wish to live, having a portion of your portfolio in low volatility, non-registered safe investments that you can use in a downturn can minimize sell low scenarios. Although I hate the opportunity cost having too much money in low, tax inefficient investments and would suggest not overdoing this unless you’re a very conservative investor, having some safe money to draw on when your stock portfolio is down 15% makes sense if your last name isn’t Musk.

Prioritize your TFSAs over your RRIFs

Although there are exceptions to this rule, particularly if the plan is to quickly replace any TFSA withdrawals the next year, I really like continuing to fund TFSA throughout retirement and instead draw down RRIFs. Returning to my mantra of flexibility, having a pot of money that can be accessed tax-free and later replaced is a wonderful thing. And if one spouse dies with a fully loaded TFSA, it can continue to grow tax-free in the survivor’s hands. Moreover, if the survivor never needs the funds, prioritizing preserving TFSAs over RRIFs can ultimately mean more after-tax dollars for future generations, particularly if tax rates continue to climb.

I was puzzling through the issue of trying to best explain the benefits of pulling money from a RRIF instead of a TFSA for living expenses despite OAS clawback for retirees who will likely pay tax at the highest rate at death and came up with an easy comparison. Assume you need $55,000 per year to fund lifestyle and can either draw $100,000 from your RRIF, which assumes a 45% tax cost, or $55,000 from your TFSA for free. In both cases, also assume that all your investments will double by the time you die in 10 years and you currently have $100,000 in both your TFSA and RRIF.

If you withdraw $100,000 from your RRIF but leave your TFSA intact, you’d have $200,000 after tax at death in your TFSA even though your RRIF is kaput. On the other hand, if you left your RRIF intact and withdrew $55,000 from your TFSA, you’d be left with $45,000 in TFSA dollars which will grow to $90,000 at your death, plus $200,000 in your RRIF. If you have to pay tax at 50% at death on that RRIF, however, you’d only be left with $100,000 after taxes. Adding the two accounts together, this totals only $190,000.  In other words, if you are able to get the money out at a lower rate now than at death, I suggest taking in from your RRIF rather than your TFSA. My example has the TFSA hoarder passing on an extra $10,000 (5%)  to his heirs on the last death. If able to withdraw RRIF dollars at less than 45% during life or paying more than 50% at death, the advantages of melting down the RRIF are even greater. Accordingly, consider funding your TFSA during retirement, even if it means pulling extra money out of your RRIF to do so, if you expect to be in higher tax bracket at death than right now.

As a first aside, it’s important to factor in OAS clawback to these calculations. Although retirees lose $.15 of their pension per dollar for each dollar their income exceeds the clawback threshold, they would have had to pay tax on that $.15 anyway, so the true impact isn’t quite so high. For example, if in a hypothetical 33.33% tax bracket, a retiree would really be out of pocket $.10  (33.33% of $.15) after taxes for every dollar clawed back. Accordingly, the total tax impact of this retiree losing some of her OAS in this scenario is 43.33% (33.33% marginal tax rate +10% extra in OAS clawback.) In some cases, after losing their entire OAS pension and no longer dealing with clawback, some retirees actually pay less tax per subsequent dollar of income until pushed into the highest tax brackets. Ultimately, unless your income is already so high that you consider your OAS pension a lost cause, it’s vital to consider the impact of the OAS clawback when creating a withdrawal strategy.

As a second aside, if comfortable with your own financial situation, consider using some of the extra RRIF money to fund your children or grandchild’s TFSAs or FHSA, or helping them fund another common tax-free growth investment – their home. If the kids are going to get what’s left anyway and you’re confident that you can’t spend all that you have, paying some tax now to fund their TFSAs or homes can make your money go further than waiting until death if you can access the money now at a cheaper rate than down the road.  Moreover, gifting with warm hands rather than cold ones allows you to actually witness the fruits of your generosity and, in many situations, a smaller gift now can actually be more impactful than a larger gift later when your kids or grandkids are no longer living in basement suites or struggling with barely affordable mortgages.

As a final point, if you expect to outlive your RRIF, noting that the tax rules currently require 20% annual withdrawals from age 95 onward, you may not need to be in as big a hurry to liquidate your RRIF.  Let’s change the previous example to assume that the tax cost of withdrawing the RRIF early remains at 45%, but that the tax cost at death is only 40% because your RRIF is a lot smaller by that point. Using the $100,000 TFSA and $100,000 RRIF scenario discussed earlier, an untouched TFSA would still be worth $200,000 at death, but the smaller TFSA and untouched RRIF would be worth a combined $210,000 net of taxes because of that lower tax bill at death on the RRIF. Ultimately, the right amount of extra money to withdraw (or not withdraw) from your RRIF is extremely situation specific.  Crunch the numbers, make honest assessments of your situation and be willing to make course corrections if your investments over or under perform or if you no longer feel confident that you will be tap dancing on your 100th birthday. If in doubt, my bias is to lean towards the solution that provides you with the most financial flexibility.

As a postscript (yes, I know I promised that the previous paragraph would be my last,) if there aren’t enough dollars to maximize one spouse’s TFSA or if it necessary to make TFSA withdrawals, consider playing the odds. At death, the deceased’s TFSA room vanishes, whereas any TFSA they pass along to the survivor can continue to grow tax-free. Accordingly, if there is a big age between spouses or one of you is looking decided more peaked, consider prioritizing funding or preserving the older / less healthy spouse’s TFSA. On that spouse’s death, the survivor would still have their own unused contribution room to use up if funds permit, plus the deceased’s fully loaded TFSA. I’ve even suggested drawing down the healthier spouse’s TFSA to fund up their partner’s account in extreme situations, such as when that  spouse has a terminal diagnosis.

RRIFs vs. Non-Registered Dollars

Assuming your TFSAs are already at capacity, and you’ve already helped your descendants as much as is prudent and affordable, whether it makes sense to accelerate your RRIF withdrawals versus melting down your non-registered portfolio involves more convoluted cogitations. While both RRIFs and TFSA allow tax-free compounding, the same is not true for non-registered portfolios except if a buy-and-hold investor that focuses exclusively on capital gains, thus receiving no dividends along the way. In other words, if your TFSA or RRIF portfolio might double before death, a non-registered portfolio owning the same investments might only grow at 75% due to the increased tax drag resulting from rebalancing and income generated and taxed along the way. Moreover, don’t forget the tax cost of withdrawing money from a RRIF in the first place, which means that much less to reinvest, which might encourage you to draw down the non-registered account first in some cases.

I’ve talked about this issue in previous articles and suggest diving into my article archives if looking for more information on the subject. The magic mix of RRIF withdrawals, whether to fund lifestyle or to merely reinvest the funds in a non-registered account, varies from situation to situation, but some of the things to consider when mulling over these matters are as follows:

  • What is the tax cost of getting RRIF money out now vs. leaving well enough alone? If you’re expecting to pay a lot more per dollar in the future, including through OAS clawback or in your terminal tax return, paying the piper ahead of schedule may still be your best option even if you don’t look as wealthy on paper at the end of the current tax year and your non-registered money won’t compound as quickly as your tax-sheltered loot.
  • What types of investments would you sell inside your RRIF and what is their tax treatment if repurchased in a non-registered account?  Dividend paying stocks owned inside a RRIF don’t benefit from either capital gains treatment or the dividend tax credit. Accordingly, selling these assets inside a RRIF and repurchasing them with what’s left after appeasing the tax man might eventually allow you to come out ahead. For example, a BC resident earning $80,000 per year would pay less than 2% tax on dividends from her non-registered portfolio each year vs as much as 53.50% at death if those dividends remain in the RRIF, continue to compound, and are eventually taxed at the highest rate. Although those dividends aren’t growing tax-free in the non-registered portfolio in this example, paying a token amount of tax each year along the way is a far better alternative than the estate having to pay through the nose when the grim reaper makes a house call.  By the same token, if the same investor is the buy and hold type, (s)he might avoid paying any tax on the growth for many years or even until death, where the tax hit if in the highest tax bracket might be as little as 50% that tax payable on the RRIF balance, depending on how capital gains are taxed at that time. Although this retiree’s investment portfolio may not look as sexy during his lifetime as a neighbour who hangs onto her RRIFs until the bitter end, his heirs might ultimately be the ones able to afford the bigger casket.

Using my earlier hypothetical $100 RRIF and assuming both neighbours had identical RRIF investments and died at the same time, if the parsimonious neighour’s RRIF doubles prior to death but is then taxed at 50%, her devastated descendants would only net $100. If the savvy gentleman down the road withdrew the same $100 from his RRIF while in a 30% tax bracket to reinvest in a non-registered account where it compounds by only 75% until death, where the $52.50 gain is taxed at 26.75%, his initial $70 investment would be worth $108.46 net of tax at his passing. Conversely, had he instead invested his $70 in a GIC, the numbers wouldn’t look nearly as good, although perhaps still acceptable. Assuming his $70 GIC portfolio grew by only 50% prior to death due to the increased tax drag, he’d still have slightly more than $100 at death, which would be the only year when taxed in the highest tax bracket.

  • What is the tax hit from selling some of your non-registered portfolio? Although you won’t pay as much tax per dollar on capital gains vs. RRIF withdrawals, if you’re up big in your non-registered portfolio, you might be better off letting those investments continue to flourish, depending on some of the other factors in this list. Of course, don’t let tax considerations block out investment considerations – if the signs suggest that it’s time to sell a stock despite its past performance or it represents too large a share of your portfolio, don’t be afraid to pull the trigger despite the resulting tax hit.
  • How much is flexibility worth to you? Slowly pulling out RRIF funds over time to build up a non-registered war chest to provide more wiggle room for larger expenses later or to allow more gifting during your lifetime may eventually be worth your while even if there are no immediate benefits, other than perhaps a bit more peace of mind.
  • What would you do with extra RRIF withdrawals? What is the after-tax return or savings if using the cash to pay down or avoid incurring debt, buying life insurance that grows and pays out for free or helping future generations? If planning to reinvest in your own name, early withdrawals to purchase GICs is far less appealing than paying down high interest credit card debt.
  • How much longer do you expect to remain above ground? The shorter your remaining lifespan, the smaller the opportunity cost of triggering taxes ahead of schedule, particularly for RRIF withdrawals that will ultimately be fully taxable at death.
  • When looking to sell non-registered winners, don’t forget to also harvest losers as well to negate all or some of the taxable gain. Moreover, if triggering a large gain will push you into the OAS clawback zone or a really uncomfortable tax bracket, consider selling in stages over multiple tax years to reduce the tax pain if there isn’t a compelling investment reason to sell the entire investment now. If approaching the end of the year, selling some in December and more in early January might make a big difference to your bottom line in some circumstances.

Conclusion

There are myriad moving parts to take into account when strategizing how to draw down income during retirement and, as is so common, one size does not fit all. Knowing your options, how the tax system works and using somewhat pessimistic assumptions that are fact-checked regularly can go a long way to making the most of your retirement assets and improving the quality of your sleep.

I will have more to say on these matters in future articles, particularly for those you who also have corporate savings to draw upon during your golden years.

Making the Right Call: The Ins and Outs & Ups and Down of Covered Call Funds

 As I’ve said many times before, few things in the investment world make me happier than receiving nice fat deposits into my investment accounts on a regular basis.  I may have never been to Mississippi, but I strongly suspect that I’d have a strong affinity to the Show Me State. 

I get even more excited when I know that I won’t have to share too large a portion of those juicy payments with the government come tax time. As I have been known to repeat ad nauseum, it’s not what you make, but what you keep after fees and taxes that really matters. Inside registered accounts, all distributions are treated the same. Accordingly, it’s irrelevant how you make your money in such accounts, so long as it’s an appropriate investment for your temperament and circumstances. On the other hand, how you get paid inside a non-registered account, whether in your personal or a corporate account can matter a heck of a lot. That’s where covered call mutual funds or etfs (I’ll use “funds” to describe both hereafter) might really shine.

Background

Put in simplest terms, a fund that “writes” or sells covered calls trades some of the potential upside from the stocks they are selling call options on in exchange for an upfront payment called an “option premium.”  Using an example, if you own a stock worth $100, you might sell someone the right or option to purchase that same stock from you for $103 any time over the next month in exchange for an extra $.50 right now. If the stock never hits this value, the option will expire as worthless and the person purchasing the call will be out $.50 with nothing to show for it. You, on the other hand, will get to keep the stock, any dividend income paid on it, plus the up-front $.50 option premium payment.  And, if you’re so inclined, you can start from scratch and sell another call option the next month.

Conversely, if the stock soars to $105 prior to the option expiring, you will be required to sell at $103 (or buy back the option) and miss out on that extra $2 of profit.  So, although you are stuck selling a stock worth $105 for $2 less than market value, you still realized a $3 on the increase of value, any dividends issued, plus the $.50 option premium. Accordingly, although you didn’t do as well as if you hadn’t sold a call option or the person who purchased it who and made a 300% profit, you still have a lot to smile about. And, if you’d been collecting options premiums on that same stock for several months before it was “called away,” (forced to sell your stock at the price stipulated  or “strike price”), you still might still be ahead of the game compared to simply buying and holding that stock.

Finally, if the stock goes down over the call period, although you’re probably not too happy about this, at least you’re $.50 better off from receiving the call premium than the guy down the street that owed the same stock but didn’t write a call. And, if you were a retiree on tight budget, the extra $.50 in call premium per share may mean not having to sell as many shares during a setback to pay for groceries.  In summary, covered call funds usually underperform typical funds in a rising stock market but the higher income they generate vs. owing a similar basket of individual shares might be very attractive to more risk-adverse or income-hungry investors more interested in monthly payments than growth.

Option Pricing Basics

In the example I provided, I arbitrarily pulled numbers out of the air in order to explain the general concept. The value of any call option is highly variable and is affected by the following:

  • The prospects and volatility of the underlying stock: A stock that goes up and down like gymnast on speed generates a higher premium than a staid blue chip special, as the upside if the riskier stock catches fire during the option period is that much higher and, thus, enticing.
  • General Market Volatility:  As you might expect, not only does a specific stock’s volatility affect what you can charge for an option premium, but so does that of the stock market as a whole. For example, options premiums will be a lot higher during an event like a global pandemic than when all is sunbeams and moonshine.
  • The Length of the Option Period: If you write an option that lasts 3 months, you should be entitled to a higher option premium than writing one that lasts a single month, since whoever purchases the option has three times as long to strike it rich and for a hot stock to keep on climbing.
  • The Difference Between Strike Price and the Stock’s Current Value.  In my example, the “strike price” of the option was $103 for a stock currently trading at $100. If the strike price was only $102, the option premium will be higher since there is that much better price of the option eventually “being in the money” and rewarding the buyer. Likewise, as you’re agreeing to surrender more of the upside if pricing the strike price close to the current value, it only makes sense if you’re paid more in exchange. Finally, the increase in the option premium as the difference between the strike price and market price decreases can increase significantly as buyer risk goes down and seller opportunity cost rises. Accordingly, if the seller in my original example was selling a call option for $101 or even one that is already “in the money” such as a $100 call option, they should expect to get significantly more than the $.50 option premium from my example.

Advanced Lessons

As you might expect, things are not quite as simple as the example I’ve described above when looking at this strategy inside a fund versus on a single stock basis. Different companies have different strategies, so it’s important to understand how the various funds differ from each other before deciding on what does (or doesn’t work) best for you.  Here are a few of the things to consider:

  • Do you believe in that market sector? In basic terms, if you don’t like the sector, don’t chase the income stream on the related covered call funds, or at least limit your exposure. And, even if you like the sector, beware of too much of a good thing in case your hunch doesn’t pan out. Consider a basket of different covered calls funds with different holdings or look into funds that do this for you rather than merely buying sector specific funds.
  • On what percentage of the fund are they writing calls? Most covered call funds don’t write calls on the entire fund. Accordingly, the more shares that aren’t optioned, the more potential upside in a rising market vs. a fund that has written calls on a higher percentage of its holdings.  When comparing funds, take this into account rather than merely focusing on yield. The higher portion of a fund’s shares that aren’t optioned, the better the upside in a rising market.
  • What is the maximum percentage of a fund that can be optioned? Many funds target a set yield and will write just enough options each month so that the combined dividend and covered call premium yield generates the desired yield. Accordingly, in more volatile times, a fund may not need to write as many call options to hit their yield targets if each call option pays a higher option premium than during a quieter market. That said, funds may also restrict the maximum percentage of shares optioned at any one time. One way or the other, it’s good to know both what’s going on right now and the limits on how much can ultimately be optioned away if circumstances change.
  • What is the fund’s typical spread between the market value of the shares optioned and the strike price of the options and how variable is this?  As explained earlier, the tighter the spread, the higher the option premium. In fact, some funds have recently started selling call options that are “in the money” or where price for exercising the option equals the market value of the share. I’ve seen funds like this generate income of the mid-teens but it’s important to remember that you will be giving up the entire upside on all optioned shares in that scenario, which may sting in a rising market. Conversely, when the market hits the skids, these funds should outperform similar options-free funds. Returning to the previous bullet, it’s also vital to know what percentage of the underlying stocks are optioned, as the non-optioned portion of the fund can still appreciate during a rising market. Accordingly, unless the market has gone gangbusters, to use a technical term, such funds may still hold their own when the market enjoys modest but not monumental gains.
  •  Do the funds use leverage? There are several covered call funds out that borrow to purchase perhaps 25% more of the underlying shares, using the extra dividend yield from the extra shares and covered call premiums to cover the borrowing costs. This might allow the funds to more fully participate in rising markets if it means less of the underlying shares are optioned but are more likely to take it on the chin when the market falls. I would also expect that as interest rates decrease and the fund’s borrowing costs decline that such funds would not need to write as many options to generate the target distribution, further increasing their performance against their covered call peers in a rising market.
  • How long has the fund been around and what’s its track record? The new breed of covered call funds that issue “in the money” options has captured a lot of interest but it’s really hard to gauge their performance against both other covered call funds that employ less aggressive option writing strategies and against more traditional funds that don’t employ options at all. The high yield is amazing and may be answer enough for some, but it’s hard to make an accurate basis of comparison without the necessary historical data. The study I discuss later in this article raises some concerns regarding traditional covered calls. Although a juicy yield is a wonderful thing, keep an eye on the fund’s overall performance. Even better, look at its long term track record if one exists.
  • Fees! What does any fund charge compared to its peers?
  • How is the fund’s target distribution typically taxed? In a non-registered account,  the distribution from a covered call fund is likely a mix of things. The options premium portion is taxed as capital gains. Depending on the underlying assets in the funds, some of the income may also be eligible dividends, interest income, foreign income or tax-deferred return of capital. Although interest income is usually the least desirable, a lot depends on your tax bracket, as eligible dividends may be disastrous for investors relying on the GIS, nirvana for those with slightly higher tax brackets and not nearly as good as capital gains for investors making the really big bucks. While an investment’s raw yield usually grabs the headlines, knowing what you’ll ultimately get to keep after taxes can help you make a more informed choice. That said, it’s a dangerous thing to make investment choices solely by focusing on taxation.

Additional Thoughts and Arguments Against

There are concerns in some quarters that the chase for option income can actually reduce total returns, such as identified in Larry Swedroe of Alpha Architect’s November 24, 2023 article (A big thanks to Moneysaver reader Dave Reid for sending this along!) That article compares the performance of some covered call funds vs. similar funds that don’t use this strategy and cited another study that concluded that over the study period (1999-2023) that a Nasdaq-focused covered call etf didn’t do nearly as well as a standard, cheaper etf tracking the same index. It also pointed out that a standard etf may be more tax efficient since more of its return translates to deferred capital gains. Finally, it also concluded that the smaller the spread between the option strike price and the stock’s trading price at issue, the worse the fund’s overall performance. In other words, the income from the call options didn’t fully compensate investors for surrendering upside.

This article raises many good points, although I would have loved to have seen a Canadian-based example. In an example where the underlying Nasdaq stocks averaged over 16% annual growth, it is no surprise that the covered call version drastically underperformed. 

In defense of covered calls, I think that merely focusing on the total return can also lead to “sequence of return problems” for investors dependent on their portfolios to pay for their daily bread. As I’ve written about previously when discussing the “sequence of returns,” or when an investment has its good vs. bad years rather than its overall performance, having to liquidate stocks during a correction to pay the internet bill can have a disastrous impact a portfolio’s long-term performance, as it forces investors to “sell low.”  Such investors may not have the luxury to wait until the stock market cooperates  and might instead appreciate a higher income along the way, particularly if they don’t need to shoot the lights out to stay on track for their ideal retirement.

Conclusion

Ultimately, like in so many areas of life, there are pros and cons to every decision. Although wealthier clients with a long time horizon, higher risk appetite and no need to generate extra income may do better with more traditional funds, more income-dependent or conservative investors may look at their investment options very differently. And, if you are one of them and are considering covered calls to help ensure that you have enough to fund your monthly premium peanut butter habit or to sleep soundly at night, I hope this article has helped in your investigation.